Posted by
BrianCrnobrnja on Wednesday, February 04, 2009 10:41:59 PM
The latest from Obama on the "stimulus" package naysayers included this assessment...
"These criticisms echo the very same failed economic theories that led
us into this crisis in the first place -- the notion that tax cuts
alone will solve all our problems; that we can ignore fundamental
challenges like energy independence and the high cost of health care;
that we can somehow deal with this in a piecemeal fashion and still
expect our economy and our country to thrive."
Obama
contends that an economic policy solely of tax cuts got us where we are
today. How accurate is this statement? Virtually nobody would be in
disagreement that the severity of our current downturn was fast-tracked
by the housing bubble. The cause of our housing problems was the
government deciding they wanted to try their hand at increasing
homeownership. It was the government (Barney Frank, Chris Dodd, and
their fellow ideologues) who made Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac's primary
responsibility to create and buy unconventional loans for people who
the private industry otherwise had determined were uncreditworthy. The
"Wall Street Greed" that everyone points to is secondary, if not
irrelevant, when considering that private enterprise did not get the
ball rolling when it comes to credit giveaways for those who were
previously denied.
Circle back to Obama's statement that a
policy of tax cuts alone is what got us here. This rhetoric swiftly
ignores the reality of what the housing crisis meant to this economic
downturn, and avoids discussion of the cascading events that led up to
it. Those who are responsible for screwing up the housing market with
their selfish, vote-mongering, unsustainable fantasy of putting people
in homes they can't afford are getting off scot-free.
What
problem in our economy can be linked to tax cuts? Who ever spent less
money after having their tax burden decreased? What company ever cut
their workforce as a result of lowered corporate tax rates?
What
we are experiencing now is the superior abilities of politicians at
their worst. If Obama and the Democrats get their way, this will go
down as the most opportunistic power grab and concession of economic
freedom that our country has ever seen. They very well may get their
way, based on their successful squashing of independent thought. Obama
is making the rules now. He is telling everyone that "tax cuts alone"
are what dug this hole, and we can only be saved if we do what he says.
And everyone is listening.
What we are missing is an honest
discussion of the merits of what's on the table. Central planners
attempting to direct an economy through borrowing, spending, and
telling people what to produce and what to buy has a long history
dating back to the ancient times. Why isn't this information being
considered front and center?